Accessibility Tools

Patient stories

  • I had both hips done within a year! Dr. Edgington was perfect for the job. My recovery was very fast, golfing within 6 weeks of both surgeries. He was very thorough in explaining what would happen. My PT helped me recover faster also. I feel like a brand new body at age 72! He is the best!
    Source: google review1
  • Dr. Edgington operated on my right hip in August and my left hip in November of 2023. I am pain free for the first time in years. He is a wonderful surgeon who handles “all the hard cases” with a terrific staff. I would find him in a heartbeat should I need more help. He has four locations making him easy to access. I am very lucky to have found him for surgery.
    Source: google review2
  • Six and one half weeks ago I had excruciating pain in my left knee and could barely walk even with a walker! My quality of life was terrible. Dr. Edgington replaced my left knee and today I walk without a cane and absolutely no pain. He gave me my life back and I shall remain forever grateful. I highly recommend him and his entire staff. They are proficient, caring and friendly.
    Source: google review3
  • I had a total right hip replacement by Dr. Edgington in October 2023 and am so thankful for his expertise and skill as a surgeon and diagnostician. I initially scheduled a consultation with Dr. Edgington because I thought I needed a knee replacement. He quickly determined the main cause of my chronic, debilitating pain was my right hip. He thoroughly explained the x-ray and the risks and benefits of hip replacement. Surgery was scheduled in 3 weeks but I honestly did not believe my pain would resolve. The day of the surgery was very easy for me, the pre-surgical staff, surgical staff, post-op and the ortho floor staff were exceptional and I was up walking within 6 hrs of surgery. I am now 6 weeks post-op and have been pain free since the day of surgery! The physical therapy with home health and outpatient therapy is greatly improving my range of motion and stability in walking. I highly recommend Dr. Edgington, along, with Brittany, his surgical P.A. for your joint replacement needs.
    Source: google review4
  • Dr. Edgington is kind, empathetic, professional , knowledgeable and an awesome surgeon. I came to him a couple of years ago because of bone on bone left knee pain. I ultimately knew that I would eventually need Total Knee replacement surgery (TKRS), however I was not ready at the time to go the surgery route. Dr. Edgington gave me other options to assist in controlling my pain until I was ready for TKRS. Well, I finally decided to have the surgery about 3 months ago. Needless to say I was nervous before the surgery . Dr. Edgington and his staff were very kind and reassuring, which tremendously help calm my nerves . The surgery was a success! My pain was minimal after the surgery. I am feeling better and walking better. Wish I’d done it much sooner. I would 100 percent recommend Dr. Edgington for your Orthopedic needs.
    Source: google review5
  • In January, 2022 I had a full hip surgery in which I had broke the femur above and below the joint. Dr. Edgington performed the surgery. I was impressed by his professionalism, his expertise, and his gentle caring personality. He was always available pre and post surgery. He takes a personal interest in you. It’s been two years, and people ask me about my hip. I tell them my hip is great. I do anything and go anywhere I want, free of pain. I even forget that I have an implant! I highly recommend Dr. Edgington without reservation.
    Source: google review6
  • This is Mary Decker. Two years ago my old half knee replacement failed. I was in a lot of pain. I found Dr. Edgington, thank God. He had me get a special CAT scan, that was used to make a new knee for my leg. I have had other knee replacements and they were horrible. This time it was different. With Dr. Edgington's expertise, I experienced very little pain and didn't even have to go to Physical Therapy for recovery. I did the exercises at home and healed quickly. Dr. Edgington was always there if I had a question or needed anything. I said to a nurse while I was in the hospital, isn't he a wonderful Doctor? She said he isn't just a wonderful Doctor, he is a wonderful human being. Well, that says it all. Kind, caring, and an expert in his field.
    Source: google review7
  • Dr Edgington replaced both my hips. He is both professional and friendly. He is everything you would want a Dr and surgeon to be. I highly recommend therapy as part of your recovery. I highly recommend him if your thinking about a surgical procedure regarding hips.
    Source: google review8
  • Total hip replacement surgery Dr Edgington does the surgery in the front part of the leg which makes recovering much faster because he does not cut through the muscle. I used a walker two days a cane for three more days.
    Source: google review9
  • Dr. Jonathan Edgington repaired my broken FEMUR bone on Nov.18,2021. I was a pedestrian hit by a car on Nov,17th & transported to St. Mary's Hospital in Hobart, Indiana. Following surgery & therapy, we met 4 separate times to view my xrays & discuss progress. He was always informative, sympathetic & very positive about my progress. Grateful for his excellent service.
    Source: google review10
  • I would like to share my experience with 2 total hip replacements. I had been in a wheelchair, unable to walk, and in excruciating pain for 2 ½ years. Several other MDs told me I had “expected” bone deterioration “for my age” and there was nothing they could do. Then I met Dr. Edgington. After diagnostic work and careful interviewing, we discussed hip replacements. When I expressed hesitation , Dr. Edgington did not dismiss any of my issues but always listened carefully and did his best to work with me. He always strived to be pro-active in preventing negative situations and experiences for me. In addition, I came to him after I had experienced an attitude of ageism and condescension from other MDs. On the other hand, Dr. Edgington quickly assessed my level of ability to comprehend the medical information and treated me accordingly, with respect and consideration, in spite of my advanced years. Upon the completion of the 2nd hip replacement, I essentially walked out of the hospital, to the car, and never looked back. Now, after 2 years, I have still nothing but positive reports.
    Source: google review11
  • This guy is an absolute rockstar! He took care of our Grandma like she was his!! Outstanding Surgeon, Awesome Bedside Manner, Friendly Staff, and Phenomenal Post-Op/Follow up care! A man who in addition to being a very talented surgeon, has retained the human aspects and truly has a caring heart!! Ryan and Gina Kennedy ( patient Judy)
    Source: google review12
  • Dr. Edgington is very professional and personable. I just had an exam and an extremely informative consultation with him in regard to my arthritic hip. I left our meeting with a very clear plan moving forward. Highly recommend.
    Source: google review13
  • Best of the Best. Explained the surgery in detail before and after having both hips replaced. Haven't had any problems and would highly recommend Jonathan MD, very caring.
    Source: google review14
  • Dr. Edgington is a exquisite doctor/surgeon! He is very knowledgeable about the body and how it works and heals. He is also very patient and understanding. I am not the happiest patient when I’m in pain but he and his staff are always pleasant and patient! Thank you!
    Source: google review15
  • I saw Dr Eddington at CCNI at 1545 W Lincoln Hwy, Schererville, Indiana. The doctor was very patient and caring and answered all of me y questions. The office was modern and clean and all of the office staff were friendly and helpful.
    Source: google review16
  • Highly recommend Edgington he is like a surgeon god his work speaks for itself
    Source: google review17
  • Great surgeon who treats patients as if they were his own family!
    Source: google review18
  • Dr. Edgington replaced my right hip February 2024. From the first consultation appointment, he and his staff have been exceptional. Explains well, listens well, and never seems in a hurry. His PA Brittany is wonderful too, able to sent any questions through MyChart to her/Dr and receive quick resp...
  • Dr. Edgington Preformed an Anterior approach total Hip Replacement 12/20/2023. My right hip ruined from arthritis the pain and inflammation was awful, he told Me let do this surgery and you will be pain free! Well 2wks walking with a cane, 3 wks no walking aid and driving,6wks no restrictions to spe...
  • I went to Dr Edgington with a worn out partial knee replacement. We discussed whether to have another partial implant to fix the bad portion or have a total knee replacement. At his recommendation I had a total knee replacement. Surgery and therapy went very well. At eight weeks post surgery I am ba...
  • I was referred to Dr Edgington by another physician to see about a knee revision Dr Jonathan was very thorough and explained what had to be done for this revision after the surgery and a month and a half of therapy . I was very happy with the results and would recommend Dr Edgerton to all my friends...
  • Dr. Edgington is a exquisite doctor/surgeon! He is very knowledgeable about the body and how it works and heals. He is also very patient and understanding. I am not the happiest patient when I’m in pain but he and his staff are always pleasant and patient! Thank you!
  • Dr. Edgington is very professional and personable. I just had an exam and an extremely informative consultation with him in regard to my arthritic hip. I left our meeting with a very clear plan moving forward. Highly recommend.

Write a review

If you're interested in submitting a testimonial for Jonathan Edgington, MD, Please use the form below to do so.


Fields marked (*) are required

Contact with Dr. Edgington Locations & Directions